Revolvers and semi-automatic pistols differ in shape, size, and carry style, and holsters are often designed specifically for one or the other. Here’s what to consider when choosing a holster for a revolver versus a semi-auto:
Form Factor Differences
Revolvers:
-
Revolvers have a bulkier mid-section due to the cylinder. This round bulge means revolver holsters are generally molded with a wider center to accommodate it.
-
The barrel is usually fixed to the frame, and many revolvers have longer barrels (4, 6 inches or more for hunting or target models). Holsters for those often cover the full length. Snub-nose revolvers (2 inches or less) have very short holsters correspondingly.
-
The shape around the trigger guard and frame can be quite different from a flat semi-auto, meaning a holster molded for a Glock will not fit a revolver shape at all, and vice versa.
Semi-Automatic Pistols:
-
Semis are flatter on the sides and often more rectangular in cross-section (slide shape). Holsters for semis are molded with flatter profiles to grip the slide and trigger guard.
-
Many semis have a squared-off muzzle end (especially with accessory rails), so holsters often have a defined shape to click around the trigger guard or ejection port for retention.
-
Barrel length on semis varies, but many holsters are open-bottomed, allowing one holster to sometimes accommodate the same model in different barrel lengths (e.g., a holster for a Glock 17 might also hold a shorter Glock 19 with some empty space at bottom).
In summary, holsters are usually not interchangeable between revolvers and autos. If you have a revolver, look for holsters specifically made for that make/model or at least that frame size; the same goes for autos.
Retention and Holster Style
Revolver Holsters:
-
Many classic revolver holsters (especially for outdoors or duty use) feature a thumb break strap that goes over the back of the hammer. This is a common retention method for revolvers – it secures the gun by the hammer area and prevents the cylinder from rolling out. For single-action revolvers (like old west style), a strap might go over the hammer to keep it in place at half-cock.
-
Revolver holsters, particularly western or hunting styles, might cover a lot of the gun (full flap holsters for protection, or high ride leather with a retention strap). For example, a big hunting revolver might ride in a chest holster or bandolier holster that fully supports its weight and often has a strap.
-
Concealed carry revolver holsters (for snub-nose) tend to be specialized: pocket holsters (for dropping a snubby in a coat or pants pocket, keeping it oriented properly and covering the trigger), ankle holsters (common for backup revolvers), or IWB holsters for J-frames. These often rely on friction and the inherent shape to retain (a well-molded J-frame holster can “grab” the cylinder indents a bit).
-
The trigger guard on revolvers is often completely enclosed by quality holsters, but note: some traditional open-top designs for single-action revolvers can leave the trigger area open (because those guns were carried with an empty chamber under hammer and heavy trigger pull). However, any modern carry holster for double-action revolvers should cover the trigger.
Semi-Auto Holsters:
-
Often rely on the mold fit for retention, sometimes with screw-adjustable tension. Many kydex holsters for autos will “click” onto the trigger guard or light/laser attachment (if holster is for a light-bearing gun) to hold the gun in place.
-
Duty or tactical holsters for semis might have hoods or ALS systems that lock onto the ejection port or slide. Because semis don’t have an exposed hammer (unless an exposed-hammer model), the retention devices usually engage trigger guard or slide instead.
-
For concealed carry semis, holsters are predominantly IWB or OWB with passive retention. You rarely see thumb breaks on concealment holsters for autos nowadays (they were more common in older designs) because they add bulk and slow the draw.
-
Magazine carriers are separate; whereas some revolver holsters (like old western rigs) integrated ammo loops on the holster or belt, semi-auto holsters typically don’t hold spare magazines attached (except some “one piece” shoulder holsters or certain appendix rigs that have a mag pouch next to the gun).
Size & Carry Considerations
Revolvers:
-
Small revolvers (like a Smith & Wesson J-frame) are popular for concealed carry, and there are holsters specifically tailored to them (often with features to offset the cylinder bulge, like padding or a holster mouth that accounts for it).
-
Large revolvers are usually carried openly or in the field (hard to conceal a big .44 Magnum). Their holsters might be belt OWB holsters, crossdraw holsters (common for seated draw in hunting situations), or chest holsters. These often distribute weight over a larger area since a loaded large revolver can be quite heavy.
-
The weight distribution of a revolver (heavier toward the cylinder and frame) means a holster should support that weight. For instance, a holster that grabs around the trigger guard and cylinder can hold a revolver nicely. If you tried to put a heavy revolver in a flimsy clip-on holster meant for a lightweight plastic pistol, it might sag or even fail.
Semi-Autos:
-
Compact and subcompact pistols are popular for concealed carry and thus there is a huge variety of holsters for them. They are flatter, which generally makes them easier to conceal against the body compared to a similarly powerful revolver (which would have the cylinder bulge).
-
Full-size semis for duty or open carry often ride in robust OWB holsters with perhaps multiple retention features as mentioned.
-
Semis also have variations like rail attachments, optics, etc., which holster makers accommodate by offering specific models (something less common for revolvers, which rarely have those accessories).
-
The slide length in a semi-auto holster is somewhat forgiving: a longer slide can often protrude out of an open-bottom holster with no issue. Revolver holsters, by contrast, typically are made for an exact barrel length – you’ll see different product codes for 2”, 4”, 6” barrels. A revolver with a 6” barrel won’t fit in a holster made for a 4” (it’ll stick out too far and the strap might not close).
Availability and Options
One practical difference: there are more holster options on the market for semi-autos than for revolvers, primarily because semis dominate the defensive carry market today. You’ll find dozens of kydex makers for Glock, SIG, Springfield, etc., and lots of innovative designs. Revolver holsters tend to be more traditional (leather is very common for revolvers). That said, the most popular carry revolvers (like the small Smith & Wesson J-frames, Ruger LCR, etc.) do have plenty of holster options, including kydex IWB and pocket holsters. But if you have a less common revolver (say a Colt Detective Special or a large-frame), your choices might be more limited and often skew toward custom leather or older style designs.
Drawing Differences: Not so much the holster, but note:
-
Drawing a revolver from a holster with a retention strap: you usually have to pop the strap off with a motion of the thumb (if a right-hand holster, usually you sweep the thumb upward as you grip to release the snap).
-
Some old revolver holsters were designed for “fanning” or quickdraw and had very little retention beyond a gravity fit (old west rigs) – these are not recommended for modern carry; they were for specific use in a very different era. Modern revolver holsters for carry will hold the gun more securely.
Trigger Guard: Revolvers often have larger trigger guards (especially with gloves in mind for hunting guns) – holsters will accommodate that. Make sure if you get a generic holster that the trigger area is indeed fully covered; sometimes a holster made for a slightly different revolver might leave a gap. Always check as part of fit (like we discussed in the fitment guide).
Conclusion
When selecting a holster, always pick one designed for your type of gun. If you switch from a semi-auto to a revolver or vice versa, you’ll likely need different holsters. Acknowledging the differences:
-
Holsters for revolvers cater to the cylinder shape, often use straps for retention (especially in open carry), and come in styles ranging from deep concealment (pocket, ankle) to heavy-duty field rigs.
-
Holsters for semi-autos cater to the flat slide, use molded retention or modern locks, and come in countless concealment configurations and tactical setups.
Neither is “better” – it’s all about matching the holster to the firearm. Both types of holsters will securely hold the gun if properly made; they just go about it in ways fitting the gun’s design. Always ensure your holster fully secures and protects the trigger of your firearm, whether it’s wheelgun or bottomfeeder!