If you’re going to carry a firearm every day, comfort is more than just a luxury – it’s practically a necessity. An uncomfortable holster can dig into your side, make you constantly adjust your gun (which can be unsafe and also blow your concealment), or even discourage you from carrying at all. The goal is to find a holster that you can forget about most of the day, even while it keeps your gun secure and accessible. Here’s how to choose a holster with comfort in mind, and some tips to make daily carry as comfortable as possible.
Consider Holster Design and Profile
The design of the holster plays a big role in comfort:
-
Width and Stability: Generally, holsters that spread out the weight of the gun over a larger area tend to feel more comfortable. For instance, an IWB holster with two belt clips (spaced apart) distributes pressure better than one with a single clip right on top of the gun. A wider “footprint” means no single spot is pressing hard into your body.
-
Thin vs. Padded: Some holsters, like all-Kydex designs, are very thin but also rigid. Others, like hybrid holsters, have a thicker but softer backer (often leather or padded polymer). There’s a trade-off here: the thinner holster has less bulk and can feel cooler (less material against you), but the padded holster might cushion the gun better. Many find that a bit of cushioning (like a suede or neoprene backing) greatly enhances comfort for IWB carry because it eliminates hard edges against the body.
-
Rounded Edges: Look for holsters that are well-finished. Sharp corners or edges are your enemy. Leather holsters typically have naturally smooth edges. For Kydex, many good manufacturers will polish or bevel the edges. If you feel sharp edges on a holster, that area will likely become a pressure point or cause chafing.
-
Sweat Guard: This is the part of the holster that extends upward between your body and the rear of the slide. A full sweat guard can keep sharp or abrasive parts of the gun (sights, slide serrations, hammer) off your skin – which can improve comfort. However, some prefer a mid or low sweat guard to avoid having too much material. It’s a personal preference, but it’s worth considering if the holster has one and how it’s shaped.
-
Holster Cant (Angle): A holster that allows you to adjust the angle it rides can help you find a more comfortable position. For example, tilting the holster forward (FBI cant) might make the grip tuck in more and feel better against your ribs or reduce printing. The angle can also help with drawing comfort vs. sitting comfort – so adjustable cant is a plus when dialing in daily comfort.
Match the Holster to Your Body and Carry Position
Body types and carry positions interact in ways that affect comfort:
-
A holster that is comfy for one person at 3 o’clock might poke another person in the thigh when they sit. Pay attention to your build. Do you have a bit of a belly? Appendix carry might cause the gun to press uncomfortably into your abdomen when you bend. In that case, a holster towards the side might ride in the natural hollow just above or behind the hip.
-
Conversely, if you have a very slim build, appendix carry might actually be more comfortable (nothing on your hips to press on). Some holsters are explicitly designed for appendix carry, with features like a foam wedge or angled pad that tilts the muzzle away from digging into you.
-
If possible, try holsters in different positions (appendix, hip, behind hip) to see what your body favors. Often, sliding an IWB holster just an inch or two forward or back can significantly change the comfort level. There’s a “sweet spot” on everyone – where the holster rides in a little pocket of space or along a flatter part of your body.
Also consider ride height (how high or low the holster sits on the belt). A low-riding holster (deep concealment) might jam the gun’s butt into your flesh when you sit, whereas a higher-ride holster might poke your ribs or print more. Many holsters have adjustable ride height – use that to fine-tune where it sits best for comfort and concealment balance.
Belt Choice and Carry Rig
A common mistake is blaming the holster for discomfort when part of the issue is actually the belt. A flimsy or narrow belt will allow the holster to move, sag, or tilt away from the body, which can cause hot spots or constant shifting. A sturdy purpose-made gun belt will keep the holster in place and distribute the weight around your waist. This not only improves safety and concealment but also comfort – no more hitching up your pants or readjusting the holster each time you stand up.
If comfort is a major concern, invest in a quality gun belt that matches how you carry (thickness and width that fit your holster loops/clips). Some modern “EDC belts” even look like regular casual belts but have a reinforced core. They can make a world of difference in how comfortable your holster feels after a few hours.
Additionally, consider the overall weight of your carry setup. A heavy steel-framed gun will be harder to carry comfortably than a lighter one. If you’re on the fence between two pistol options and one is significantly lighter, that might be a factor if daily comfort is key.
Holster Material and Breathability
This overlaps with design, but specifically think about how the material feels:
-
Leather against skin can initially be a bit stiff, but it warms up and conforms. In hot weather, leather can get sweaty, but leather “breathes” more than solid plastic.
-
Kydex directly against skin (for example, a minimalist holster) might cause sweat to bead since it’s not absorbent at all. Some people don’t mind a bit of sweat, others do. You can wear an undershirt as a buffer if needed.
-
Hybrid holsters often use a breathable neoprene or suede backing that can help with moisture and comfort.
-
If you live in a very hot climate, you might lean toward holsters that minimize skin contact (smaller footprint holsters) or materials that handle sweat well (synthetics that won’t soak it up and get slimy).
User Testimonials and Trials
Comfort is subjective, so it helps to see what others with similar needs say. For example, if you know you want to carry a certain model of gun, look up forums or reviews where people discuss carrying that gun – they might mention which holster was most comfortable for them and why. Perhaps a particular holster had a feature like a memory foam wedge that made appendix carry comfortable, etc.
However, be careful not to take one person’s experience as gospel. We all have different body shapes and tolerance. If possible, try borrowing or testing a friend’s holster, or buy from companies that have good return/exchange policies so you can try the holster and send it back if it just doesn’t fit you right.
Tips for Maximizing Comfort with Any Holster
-
Position Carefully: As mentioned, an inch of adjustment can help. Also, when sitting down, you might find yourself instinctively adjusting the holster – take note of what you’re doing (e.g., do you push it up or down slightly when driving?) and see if setting it there preemptively helps.
-
Use Padding if Needed: Don’t be afraid to improvise. Some users add moleskin (a soft adhesive fabric) to certain spots on a holster that rubs them. There are also aftermarket foam wedges you can attach to holsters (commonly used in appendix carry) that greatly enhance comfort by angling the gun and adding cushion.
-
Dress Around It: The right clothing can make holster carry much more comfortable. Pants with a bit more room in the waist and thighs, a belt that isn’t cinched to the last notch (the gun belt will keep things up so you don’t need to overtighten), and shirts that allow some air flow can prevent the holster from digging in or chafing. If you tuck in your shirt with an IWB holster, consider using an undershirt – it provides a layer between you and the holster.
-
Holster Placement When Not Standing: If you’re seated for long periods (like driving), you might tweak your carry method. Some people who carry appendix will shift the holster slightly off-center or even remove the gun from the holster (if legal and safe to do so, such as when driving long distance and the gun can be secured near at hand). The point is to listen to your body – if something is killing your back or belly after 2 hours in the car, explore an adjustment or a different carry position for those times.
-
Rotate Gear for Skin Rest: It might sound odd, but if one particular holster rubs a certain spot on you, you can rotate between two holsters on different days to give your skin a break. Just like rotating shoes can prevent blisters, rotating holsters or positions can keep one spot from getting overly irritated daily until you build up a tolerance.
The Comfort vs. Concealment Balance
Finally, remember there is a balance between comfort, concealment, and quick access. A super comfortable setup (like a very padded holster) might be bulkier and slightly less concealable. Or a holster that’s extremely concealed (deep inside the waistband) might be a bit slower to draw or uncomfortable to wear low. You often have to find a personal sweet spot on this spectrum.
The good news is that with the huge variety of holsters on the market, you can likely find one that suits your needs. Comfort should not be sacrificed entirely – a holster can be safe and concealable and reasonably comfortable. It might take some trial and error, but once you find the right holster (and get used to the sensation of carrying, which in itself takes a bit of time), you’ll likely be able to carry all day without a second thought. At that point, your holster is doing its job: keeping you armed and prepared, without constantly reminding you that it’s there.