Holsters are often designed with a specific carry method in mind: open carry or concealed carry. The requirements and priorities for each can differ significantly. Let’s compare what makes a holster suitable for open carry versus concealed carry:
Visibility and Design
-
Open Carry Holsters: These are meant to be worn visibly. Commonly, they are OWB (outside the waistband) holsters worn on the belt, thigh, or chest. Because concealment isn’t a concern, open carry holsters can be larger, made of sturdier (and sometimes bulkier) materials, and often have features like retention hoods or straps (more on that later). They might be brightly colored or have tactical appearances (since there’s no need to hide them).
-
Concealed Carry Holsters: These are designed to keep the firearm hidden. They tend to be more compact and low-profile. Many are IWB (inside the waistband) to tuck the gun against your body under clothing. Even OWB holsters marketed for concealed carry will be contour-hugging and likely ride high so a shirt or jacket easily covers them. In terms of aesthetics, they’re often neutral in color and minimalistic because they’re not meant to be seen at all.
Retention Levels
-
Open Carry: Since the firearm is exposed to the public, retention is a bigger concern for open carry holsters. There’s a risk (however small) of someone attempting to grab an openly carried gun, especially law enforcement who open carry as part of uniform. Therefore, many open carry or duty holsters have active retention mechanisms: thumb breaks, retention hoods, locking triggers (like ALS, SERPA, etc.). For example, a police duty holster might be Level III, meaning it has three retention features (like a strap, a hood that must be flicked, and a friction lock). Even for civilian open carry, it’s wise to have at least some active retention beyond mere friction, for peace of mind that the gun can’t easily be snatched.
-
Concealed Carry: Here, the logic is that since the gun is hidden, the primary retention is that no one knows it’s there. Concealed holsters typically rely on passive retention (friction/tight molding). They seldom have thumb breaks or complex locks because those can slow your draw, and concealment holsters prioritize a quick, unhindered draw in self-defense. You won’t usually see a Level II retention IWB holster – it would be considered overkill and add bulk. The assumption is if you need to draw, you want the least resistance from the holster since concealment already provided a layer of security. (However, the trigger guard protection is still absolute, as always.)
Comfort and Carry Position
-
Open Carry: Often done in contexts like on duty, at the range, hunting, or on private property. Comfort considerations here are slightly different. An open carry rig might be a paddle holster, a thigh rig, or a chest holster. These can be very comfortable because they’re not tucked in your pants; however, they might be heavy or require adjustments to distribute weight (like a thigh strap to stop a drop-leg holster from flopping). Because the gun isn’t pressed against you under clothing, sweat and body heat on the gun/holster are less of an issue (except perhaps for chest carry while hiking). Open carry holsters can be larger in footprint – not an issue when you’re not trying to conceal.
-
Concealed Carry: Comfort is crucial because the gun/holster is typically pressed against your body all day. IWB holsters have to balance being slim with not poking you too much. Concealed carry holsters often have features to enhance comfort – like padding, flexible wings, or smaller profiles – because if it’s not comfortable, you won’t carry consistently. Also, concealed carry often positions the gun in places like appendix or hip under a belt; those positions benefit from softer edges and thoughtful design to avoid chafing or pressure points. Concealed holsters also consider things like sweat guards, since the holster is between your body and the gun, to protect the firearm from sweat and your skin from sharp edges.
Accessibility and Speed
-
Open Carry: Typically, drawing from an open carry holster (especially OWB on the hip) is very fast – there’s no garment to clear. On the downside, retention devices mean you might have an extra step (like pressing a thumb lever or unsnapping a strap) to get the gun out. Well-trained users can still draw quickly from Level II or III holsters, but it does require practice. Open carry also means you might carry a larger handgun (full-size), which can be easier to shoot accurately, and the holster will accommodate that size without worry of concealment.
-
Concealed Carry: The draw is a bit more complex because you must move clothing out of the way. The holster itself usually presents less resistance (no straps), so once the shirt/jacket is cleared, the gun can come out quickly. Many concealed carriers choose mid-size or compact guns to make concealment easier; holsters for these are correspondingly smaller. Some concealed carry holsters are designed for specific draw techniques (e.g., pocket holsters orient for a pocket draw, ankle holsters for an ankle draw) – those draws are inherently slower than an open hip carry, but concealment necessity sometimes demands it. The key is that a concealed carry holster should allow a reasonably efficient draw after clearing the garment. Good ones position the gun’s grip such that when you lift your covering garment, you can get a solid grip immediately.
Holster Material and Construction
-
Open Carry: Durability tends to be a big factor. Many open carry/duty holsters are made of heavy-duty materials (thick leather or injection-molded polymer) meant to withstand the elements and rough use. They might be bigger, have multiple screws, and perhaps drop-leg rigs with lots of straps – a very “tactical” build. Since they’re visible, manufacturers may add more cosmetic detailing or use basket-weave patterns (for uniform duty) since appearance can matter in uniform.
-
Concealed Carry: These holsters emphasize lightweight and thin construction, so as not to add extra girth. You’ll see a lot of kydex IWB holsters that are just two thin pieces of kydex for minimal thickness. If leather, they’ll be just thick enough to hold shape but often not as thick as a duty holster’s leather. Concealed holsters also consider wearability – e.g., flush-fitting clips, rounded edges – since they contact your clothes and body all day. They may not need to endure as much external trauma (nobody’s rappelling with their IWB holster), but they do need to endure sweat and constant movement friction.
Use Case and Mindset
-
Open Carry Use Case: You might open carry when in the backcountry, when in uniform (police/security), or in some jurisdictions as a form of normal carry if legal. Open carry holsters shine in environments where quick access is needed and concealment is not a factor. If you open carry, you accept that people will see your firearm. Thus, your holster choice often leans toward one that projects “responsible and secure” – for instance, a retention holster so observers (including law enforcement) see you are carrying safely, not just a gun tucked in your waistband with no holster (never do that!). The holster is part of your visible presentation.
-
Concealed Carry Use Case: Here the goal is low profile. You don’t want anyone aware you have a gun. The best concealed carry holster is one that no one ever notices, including yourself to a large degree. This means comfort and deep concealment are crucial, sometimes at a slight expense of the fastest possible draw or max security, though a good concealed rig balances all well. The mindset with concealed carry is to avoid confrontation (since you have the element of surprise if needed) and thus your holster just needs to stay hidden and ready.
In Summary:
-
Open carry holsters = focus on retention and ease of draw without concealment. They’re often OWB, robust, with active retention features. Great for when you don’t need to hide the gun and want maximum security and potentially faster access (assuming you practice with any retention devices).
-
Concealed carry holsters = focus on concealment and comfort. Usually IWB or otherwise tucked away, with passive retention. They prioritize being unnoticed and accessible enough for self-defense without tipping off anyone that you’re armed.
Many people actually own different holsters for different purposes. You might have a heavy-duty OWB holster for open carry at the range or in the woods, and a slim IWB holster for everyday concealed carry in public. Matching your holster to the mode of carry is important; using a bulky open-carry holster for concealment will be frustrating, and using a flimsy concealment holster for open carry could be risky (since it may not have retention against someone trying to grab it).
Choose the right tool for the job: if carrying openly, invest in a quality holster that secures the gun externally; if carrying concealed, invest in one that hides it well and stays comfortable all day. In either case, ensure the holster covers the trigger and holds the firearm securely – those are universal requirements.